A color can come from a seed, a root or an insect and still not be called "natural" on a US ingredient statement. FDA calls carmine, cochineal extract, annatto and vegetable juice colors colors exempt from certification, listed in 21 CFR Part 73, and each one has its own rule for how it is named. The wrong name is a common reason imported foods end up on FDA's import alert for unlisted colors. This is how each one goes on a label, for food, spirits and meat.
The general rule for food
Under 21 CFR 101.22(k), a color exempt from certification can be declared as "artificial color," "color added" or an equally informative term, or by its listed name: "annatto color," "colored with vegetable juice." The word "natural" is not an authorized way to declare a color. It cannot go on the ingredient statement, however the color was made.
Front-of-pack claims are a separate question. In February 2026 FDA wrote to industry that it will not object to a "no artificial colors" claim on a food that contains none of the certified colors in 21 CFR Part 74. Carmine, cochineal extract, annatto and vegetable juice colors are all Part 73 colors, so a product colored only with them can make that claim.
Carmine and cochineal extract: always by name
Carmine and cochineal extract are the one exception to "color added." Since January 5, 2011, FDA has required both to be declared by name on every food label, including butter, cheese and ice cream, where other colors need not be declared at all (21 CFR 73.100(d)). The label reads "carmine" or "cochineal extract." The rule also covers cosmetics.
Carminic acid is the molecule that gives both their color, but it is not a label name. FDA's import alert on unlisted colors has flagged imported candies and snacks whose labels listed "carminic acid." If the product contains cochineal extract, the label says cochineal extract.
Carmine is the aluminum lake of carminic acid: an insoluble pigment, or solubilized again for liquids. Cochineal extract is the carminic acid color without the lake. Both come from the cochineal insect, so neither suits a vegan product.
Annatto
Annatto extract, from the seed of the achiote tree, is declared as "annatto," "annatto color" or "colored with annatto" (21 CFR 73.30). Like other exempt colors, it need not be declared in butter, cheese or ice cream, though most labels name it anyway.
One change lands on January 11, 2027: FDA removes methylene chloride, trichloroethylene and ethylene dichloride from the solvents allowed to make annatto extract. Annatto made with any of the three will no longer meet the listing. Ask your supplier how each lot is extracted.
Black carrot and purple corn: say juice
Black carrot and purple corn colors are anthocyanins, but in the US they are listed as vegetable juice color under 21 CFR 73.260: juice expressed from an edible vegetable, or a water infusion of the dried vegetable, which may be concentrated or dried. FDA advised in 1997 that juice from black carrots can meet that listing. The label reads "vegetable juice (color)," "black carrot juice (color)" or "colored with black carrot juice."
The names used abroad do not work here. FDA's import alert on unlisted colors has flagged foods whose labels said "anthocyanin," "E163," "black carrot extract" or "black carrot concentrate." In one 2026 entry FDA wrote that the label "should state black carrot juice."
The listing describes juice and water infusions. If a supplier's anthocyanin powder is made with ethanol, a resin or enzymes, ask how its US customers declare it before you build a label around it.
Spirits and liqueurs
TTB, not FDA, sets the spirits label. Two rules apply to color.
- Disclosure. A spirit with added color says "artificially colored," unless the only colors are exempt from certification, in which case a truthful source statement such as "colored with annatto" takes its place (27 CFR 5.72). Carmine and cochineal extract must also be named: "contains carmine" or "contains cochineal extract" (27 CFR 5.63).
- Class. Carmine and cochineal extract force a gin, rum or whisky to be redesignated. Other harmless coloring keeps the class at up to 2.5% by volume. Liqueurs, cordials and amari keep their class either way, and nothing may be added to neutral spirits or straight whisky (27 CFR 5.155).
Meat and poultry
USDA FSIS lists which colors can go into meat and poultry and at what level, in Table 2 of Directive 7120.1. Its November 2026 revision lists carmine for fully cooked poultry and for soy protein gels in dry sausage, both with an "artificially colored" qualifier on the product name. Annatto is listed for casings and rendered fats, for various poultry products and, in place of FD&C Red No. 3, to tint nitrite curing salt. A colored meat product needs a check against that table before the color is chosen.
Where each color is allowed
| Color | Food ingredient statement | Spirits label | Drugs | Cosmetics |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Carmine | carmine | contains carmine | Yes | Yes |
| Cochineal extract | cochineal extract | contains cochineal extract | Yes | No |
| Annatto | annatto, annatto color | colored with annatto | Yes | Yes |
| Black carrot, purple corn | vegetable juice (color) | colored with black carrot juice | No | No |
Dietary supplements are foods, so all four can color a supplement gummy or capsule. Only carmine and annatto can color an OTC drug or a cosmetic.
Why this matters now
FD&C Red No. 3 must be out of US food by January 15, 2027, and out of ingested drugs by January 18, 2028. California bars it from food from January 1, 2027. Many of the brands replacing it, and Red 40 behind it, are putting an exempt color on a label for the first time. Getting the name right is part of the reformulation.
Carmine, cochineal extract and annatto, with samples.
PAT Ingredients supplies carmine lake and water-soluble carmine, cochineal extract and water-soluble annatto, with a certificate of analysis on every lot. Send the application and the pH and we will send the grade to trial.
Request a Sample